Home > The Orthopaedic Standard > submission guidelines
Pantheon Academic

Submission Guidelines

The Orthopaedic Standard

Author Guidelines

1. Submitting Your Manuscript

Manuscripts must be submitted through the journal’s web-based submission system in Microsoft Word format. Submissions sent by email are not considered formal submissions unless specifically requested by the editorial office.

Submission Checklist

Before submitting, please ensure that:

  • The manuscript follows the journal’s formatting and structure requirements.
  • The title page includes all authors, affiliations, contribution details, and corresponding author information.
  • The blinded manuscript does not contain author-identifying information.
  • An abstract is included where required for the selected article type.
  • Figures, tables, and supplementary files are uploaded separately and cited in the manuscript.
  • References are formatted consistently and include DOI links where available.
  • Ethics approval, consent statements, trial registration, and reporting guideline checklists are included where applicable.
  • All authors have reviewed and approved the final submitted version.

Note: Submitting a complete and properly blinded manuscript helps reduce administrative delays.

2. Article Types & Word Limits

The journal accepts a range of article types relevant to orthopaedic research, clinical practice, education, and global musculoskeletal health.

Article TypeWord LimitDescription
Original ArticlesUp to 5,000 wordsReports of original research, usually structured as Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion, and Conclusion.
Review ArticlesUp to 6,000 wordsComprehensive narrative reviews, scoping reviews, or systematic reviews of a defined topic.
Case ReportsUp to 2,500 wordsReports of unusual, educational, or clinically important cases with clear relevance to practice.
Short CommunicationsUp to 2,000 wordsBrief reports of focused findings, early observations, technical notes, or concise clinical research.
Letters to the EditorUp to 1,000 wordsCommentary, scholarly correspondence, or responses to published articles.
Educational MaterialsUp to 4,000 wordsTeaching tools, training approaches, curriculum reports, simulation methods, or educational resources.
Interesting ImagesUp to 500 wordsHigh-quality clinical, operative, radiographic, or pathological images with a concise explanatory note.

Word counts exclude abstract, references, tables, figure captions, and supplementary material unless otherwise stated by the editorial office.

3. Manuscript Preparation

Submissions should include a separate title page, a blinded manuscript, and any relevant figures, tables, supplementary material, and supporting documentation.

Title Page

  • Full manuscript title.
  • Article type and word count.
  • Full names, affiliations, and ORCID IDs of all authors where available.
  • Corresponding author name, email address, institutional affiliation, and telephone number.
  • Author contribution statement.
  • Conflict of interest statement.
  • Funding statement.
  • Acknowledgments, if applicable.
  • Ethics approval and informed consent statements, where applicable.
  • Data availability statement, where applicable.

Blinded Manuscript

  • Original Articles: Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion, and Conclusion.
  • Case Reports: Background, Case Presentation, Discussion, and Learning Points where appropriate.
  • Review Articles: Introduction, Methods or Search Strategy where applicable, main thematic sections, and Conclusion.

References

  • References should be numbered sequentially in the order they appear in the text.
  • Use square brackets in the manuscript text, for example: [1], [2], [3].
  • Include DOI links where available.
  • Ensure all references cited in the text appear in the reference list, and all listed references are cited in the text.

Tables and Figures

  • Submit tables and figures as separate files where possible.
  • Provide clear titles, legends, captions, and abbreviations.
  • Cite each table and figure in the main manuscript text.
  • Ensure images are of sufficient resolution for online publication.
  • Remove patient identifiers from all clinical images unless explicit consent has been obtained.

Supplementary Material

  • Supplementary datasets, protocols, appendices, multimedia files, and extended methods may be submitted separately.
  • Label supplementary files clearly and refer to them in the manuscript text.
  • Large supplementary files should include a brief description or table of contents.

4. Ethical Considerations

Originality and Plagiarism

  • Submitted manuscripts must be original and must not be under consideration by another journal.
  • All submissions may be screened for plagiarism, duplication, and inappropriate text reuse.
  • Manuscripts with excessive similarity, duplicate publication, or misrepresentation may be rejected or referred for further editorial review.

Research Ethics and Compliance

  • Human and animal studies: Manuscripts must include ethics approval from an institutional review board, ethics committee, or equivalent body where required.
  • Informed consent: Consent is required for studies involving identifiable human participants, clinical images, or personal medical information.
  • Clinical trials: Clinical trials must be registered in a recognized public trial registry.
  • Retrospective studies: Authors should state whether ethics approval was obtained or formally waived.

Authorship and Contributions

  • All listed authors must meet recognized authorship criteria and approve the submitted manuscript.
  • The journal expects authorship to follow ICMJE authorship principles.
  • Changes to authorship after submission require explanation, written agreement from affected authors, and editorial approval.
  • Contributors who do not meet authorship criteria should be acknowledged with permission.

Conflicts of Interest

  • Authors must disclose financial, professional, institutional, or personal relationships that could influence the work.
  • If there are no conflicts of interest, this should be stated clearly.

5. Reporting Guidelines

Authors should follow the appropriate reporting guideline for their study design. Where applicable, the completed checklist should be uploaded with the manuscript.

  • CONSORT for randomized controlled trials.
  • PRISMA for systematic reviews and meta-analyses.
  • STROBE for observational studies.
  • CARE for case reports.
  • ARRIVE for animal studies.
  • CHEERS for health economic evaluations.
  • AGREE for clinical practice guidelines where relevant.

Authors are encouraged to consult the EQUATOR Network when selecting the correct reporting guideline for their study type.

6. Review Process

Double-Blind Peer Review

  • Author and reviewer identities are anonymized during review.
  • Manuscripts are assessed for relevance, originality, methodological quality, ethical compliance, and clarity.
  • Submissions may be reviewed by at least two independent reviewers when sent for external peer review.
  • Editorial decisions may include accept, minor revision, major revision, reject and resubmit, or reject.

Revisions

  • Authors invited to revise will receive editorial and reviewer feedback.
  • Revisions should include a clean manuscript, a tracked-changes version where requested, and a point-by-point response letter.
  • Revision deadlines will be stated in the decision letter. Extensions may be requested when needed.

Appeals

  • Authors may appeal editorial decisions by submitting a clear explanation and supporting justification.
  • Appeals are reviewed by the editorial team or editorial board, as appropriate.
  • Appeals should address specific concerns about process, interpretation, or factual error rather than disagreement alone.

7. Fees & Open Access Policy

Article Processing Charges

To support open-access publication, an Article Processing Charge may apply after acceptance. The APC supports editorial administration, production, online hosting, article presentation, and long-term dissemination.

  • No APC is charged before editorial acceptance.
  • Authors are informed of applicable charges before publication.
  • Waivers or discounts may be considered for authors from eligible low-income settings or in cases of demonstrated need.
  • Articles are published under a Creative Commons Attribution license, unless otherwise stated.
  • Authors retain copyright of their work.
  • Readers may share and reuse published work in accordance with the article license, provided appropriate credit is given.

For the latest fee details, authors should refer to the journal’s open-access and fees information or contact the editorial office before submission.

8. Post-Publication Policies

Corrections and Retractions

  • Authors should notify the editorial office promptly if a significant post-publication error is identified.
  • Corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions are handled according to recognized publication ethics principles.
  • The journal may update the published record where necessary to preserve accuracy and transparency.

Data Availability

  • Authors are encouraged to make data, protocols, and analysis materials available in suitable repositories where possible.
  • Where data cannot be shared, authors should explain the reason in the data availability statement.

Promoting Your Article

  • Share the published article link through institutional, professional, and academic networks.
  • Use the official article DOI or journal URL when promoting the work.
  • Authors may contact the journal regarding promotion of selected high-impact or practice-changing studies.

9. Contact & Support

For submission support, policy clarification, or general editorial inquiries, please contact the editorial office.

Authors may contact the editorial office before submission if they are uncertain about article type, scope, formatting, ethics requirements, or supporting documentation.

Ready to Submit?

The Orthopaedic Standard welcomes rigorous orthopaedic scholarship that informs practice, improves care, and contributes to global musculoskeletal knowledge.

Submit Manuscript Contact Support