Home > The Orthopaedic Standard > submission guidelines
Pantheon Academic

Submission Guidelines

1. Submitting Your Manuscript ▼

Manuscripts must be submitted via our web-based submission system, in Microsoft Word format. Submissions sent via email will not be considered.

Submission Checklist

Before submitting, please ensure that:

  • Your manuscript follows the formatting and structure guidelines.
  • All authors and affiliations are listed correctly on the title page.
  • You have included an abstract (if required).
  • Figures, tables, and supplementary materials are correctly formatted.
  • References include DOI links where available.
  • You have uploaded all necessary supporting documents, such as reporting guideline checklists and ethics approval statements.

2. Article Types & Word Limits ▼

We accept the following types of submissions:

  • Original Articles (Max 5000 words) – Reports of new research, including Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion, and Conclusion.
  • Review Articles (Max 6000 words) – Comprehensive analyses of existing research on a specific topic. May be systematic or narrative.
  • Case Reports (Max 2500 words) – Detailed reports of unique or educational clinical cases.
  • Short Communications (Max 2000 words) – Concise research findings of significant interest.
  • Letters to the Editor (Max 1000 words) – Commentary or response to published articles.
  • Educational Materials (Max 4000 words) – Teaching tools, instructional guides, or best-practice approaches.
  • Interesting Images (Max 500 words) – High-quality images with explanatory notes highlighting rare or educational findings.

 

Word count excludes abstract, references, tables, and figure captions.

3. Manuscript Preparation ▼

Your submission should include the following documents:

1. Title Page

  • Title (clear, concise, and relevant)
  • Word count
  • Full names and affiliations of all authors
  • Corresponding author details (name, email, phone, ORCID ID)
  • Conflict of interest statement
  • Funding information
  • Acknowledgments
  • Ethics approval statement (if applicable)
  • Data sharing statement (if applicable)

2. Blinded Manuscript

  • For Original Articles: Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion, Conclusion.
  • For Case Reports: Background, Case Presentation, Discussion.
  • For Reviews: Introduction, Methodology (for systematic reviews), Thematic Sections, Conclusion.
  • References: Numbered sequentially using square brackets [1], [2], etc. Include DOI where available.

Tables and Figures

  • Submit each table and figure in a separate Word document file.
  • Provide clear headings and captions.
  • Cite all tables and figures in the main text.

Supplementary Material

  • Additional data (e.g., extended datasets, protocols, multimedia files) can be submitted separately.
  • If lengthy, include a cover page and table of contents.

4. Ethical Considerations ▼

Plagiarism & Originality

  • Manuscripts must be original and not be published or being considered elsewhere.
  • All submissions will be checked for plagiarism
  • Articles with excessive similarity to existing work will be rejected.

Research Ethics & Compliance

  • Human & Animal Studies: Must include an ethics approval statement from an institutional review board (IRB) or equivalent.
  • Informed Consent: Required for studies involving human participants.
  • Clinical Trials: Must be registered in an approved public trial registry.

Authorship & Contributions

  • All listed authors must have significantly contributed to the research.
  • Use the ICMJE authorship criteria to determine appropriate authorship.
  • Changes to authorship after submission require justification and approval.

Conflicts of Interest

  • All authors must declare any financial or personal conflicts of interest that could influence their research.

5. Reporting Guidelines ▼

Authors should follow appropriate reporting guidelines based on their study type:

 

  • CONSORT for randomized trials
  • PRISMA for systematic reviews
  • STROBE for observational studies
  • CARE for case reports

 

The checklist must be submitted alongside your manuscript. Visit the Equator Network for more details.

6. Review Process ▼

Double-Blind Peer Review

  • Author and reviewer identities are anonymized.
  • Manuscripts are assessed by at least two independent reviewers.
  • The review process typically takes 14 days, but timelines may vary.

Revisions

  • If revisions are required, authors will receive detailed feedback.
  • Revisions should be submitted within 14-21 days, with a point-by-point response to reviewer comments.

Appeals

  • Authors who disagree with editorial decisions may submit a formal appeal with justification.
  • Appeals will be reviewed by the editorial board.

7. Fees & Open Access Policy ▼

Article Processing Charges (APCs)

To support open access publishing, an Article Processing Charge (APC) of [$950] applies upon acceptance. This fee covers:

  • ✔️ Peer review and editorial support
  • ✔️ High-quality publication and indexing
  • ✔️ Global dissemination of research

 

Waivers and discounts may be available for authors from low-income countries.

 

Licensing & Copyright

  • Articles are published under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license, allowing broad distribution while crediting the original authors.
  • Authors retain full copyright of their work.

8. Post-Publication Policies ▼

Corrections & Retractions

  • If errors are identified post-publication, authors should notify the editorial office.
  • Corrections or retractions will be handled per COPE guidelines.

Data Availability

  • Authors are encouraged to share raw data or analysis scripts in public repositories where possible.

Promoting Your Article

  • Share on social media using provided journal links.
  • Distribute to colleagues via email or institutional repositories.
  • Request press releases for high-impact studies.

9. Contact & Support ▼

For submission support, policy clarifications, or general inquiries, contact our editorial office at support@pantheonacademic.com.

 

We look forward to your submission!

Back to Top